A Regulatory Gap worth Examining: Provisioning Rules on Bank Guarantees under NBE Directive SBB/90/2024
The National Bank of Ethiopia’s Asset Classification and Provisioning Directive No. SBB/90/2024 introduces clear prudential requirements for off-balance sheet exposures, including guarantees, letters of credit, and other contingent liabilities.
At the center of this framework is a simple but important rule:
- Guarantees without counter-guarantee → 2% general provision
- Guarantees backed by foreign bank/insurance counter-guarantee (A-rated) → 1% provision
- Letters of credit and other commitments → generally 2%
On paper, the logic is straightforward. The existence of a strong counter-guarantee reduces credit risk exposure, hence the lower provisioning requirement.
The Emerging Question: What if the guarantee is fully cash-covered locally?
A practical gap arises when we consider a scenario not explicitly addressed with clarity in the Directive:
What is the applicable provisioning requirement when a bank issues a guarantee but holds 100% cash collateral internally?
In such a case, the bank’s exposure is arguably fully secured by cash, meaning the risk of loss is significantly minimized compared to both:
- unsecured guarantees (2%), and
- Foreign counter-guaranteed guarantees (1%).
Yet the Directive does not explicitly introduce a differentiated provisioning category for fully cash-collateralized guarantees.
The Interpretational Tension
This creates a regulatory interpretation issue:
- Should such guarantees still fall under the 2% general provision bucket (8.3.1(a)), since there is no foreign counter-guarantee?
- Or can they be treated more favourably given the practical elimination of credit risk through cash collateral?
From a prudential perspective, provisioning is meant to reflect expected credit loss, not merely formality of structure.
However, from a strict reading of the Directive, the absence of an explicit category leaves room for conservative application often defaulting to the 2% rate.
Risk Reality vs Regulatory Form
There is also a deeper conceptual issue:
A bank that issues a guarantee backed by:
- 100% cash collateral, vs.
- Foreign A-rated counter guarantee, does not necessarily carry similar risk profiles in practice.
Yet the Directive appears to treat risk reduction primarily through the lens of counter-party substitution (foreign bank/insurer) rather than internal liquidity coverage (cash collateralization).
Why This Matters
This is not just a technical accounting issue. It affects:
- Cost of issuing guarantees for clients
- Banking competitiveness in trade finance
- Liquidity management practices in local banks
- Regulatory consistency in risk classification
Most importantly, it raises a broader question:
Should provisioning rules focus strictly on external credit enhancement, or should they equally recognize internal full-collateral protection structures?
Closing Thought
As Ethiopia’s financial system becomes more sophisticated, regulatory frameworks will increasingly need to distinguish between:
- legal form of risk mitigation, and
- economic substance of risk elimination
The current Directive is a strong step in prudential regulation, but this specific area—cash-collateralized guarantees—appears to be an interpretational gap that may warrant further clarification or guidance from the regulator.
